Rule of Four
The rule of four is the Supreme Court practice of agreeing to hear a case when at least four of the nine justices vote to grant a writ of certiorari. It is not written in the Constitution or in law; it is an internal custom that lets a minority of justices put a case on the docket.
CLEP American Government, Chapter 16
Rule of Four
Rule of Four. Under the Supreme Court's longstanding internal practice, four justices can vote to grant a petition for a writ of certiorari. The Rule of Four allows a substantial minority of the nine-member Court to place a case on the docket. It prevents five justices who are satisfied with a lower-court ruling from controlling access to review whenever four colleagues believe an important federal question warrants the Court's attention.
A grant of certiorari is a docket decision, not a decision on the merits. Four justices might vote to hear a case because federal courts of appeals have adopted conflicting rules, a lower court has decided an important federal question, or existing Supreme Court doctrine needs clarification. After full briefing and oral argument, some of those four may reject the petitioner's position, and other justices may supply the majority. A case granted by four votes can therefore end in a lopsided judgment against the party that requested review.
The practice protects minority access without giving four justices power to decide the case. Five colleagues cannot always keep an issue off the docket merely because they currently prefer the lower-court result, yet the four who vote to hear still must persuade enough justices on the merits. That design separates the institutional value of clarification from agreement with a litigant's argument.
Votes on certiorari are not ordinarily accompanied by a full public explanation. A justice may sometimes write about a denial, but readers usually cannot know why each justice voted as they did. That is another reason denial lacks precedential meaning. It can reflect vehicle problems, timing, workload, or a desire for further lower-court development rather than approval of the judgment below.
Keep three numbers and actions separate: four votes can ordinarily grant review; a majority ordinarily controls the Court's judgment when all nine participate; and denial of certiorari carries no implication that the Court approves the lower court's reasoning. The Rule of Four is not found in Article III and does not create a right to Supreme Court review. It is an internal practice governing the Court's largely discretionary appellate docket.
A CLEP distractor may say that four votes invalidate a statute or establish precedent. Four votes open the door to review. The judgment and controlling opinion come later through the merits process.
Video lesson: Supreme Court of the United States Procedures: Crash Course Government and Politics #20
Related to This Article
More math articles
- Due Process and Privacy: Rights, Procedures and Limits
- Top 10 4th Grade SBAC Math Practice Questions
- The Minnesota MCA Grade 5 Math Worksheet Set — 49 Free Printable PDFs to Print and Hand Over
- 10 Most Common 5th Grade Georgia Milestones Assessment System Math Questions
- How long is the SAT Test?
- How to Solve Math Word Problems: A Proven 5-Step System
- Feet to Meters Converter
- Top 20 Math Websites for Virtual Learning
- New Jersey NJSLA Grade 8 Math Free Worksheets: Free Printable Worksheets Covering Every Skill
- 5th Grade NYSE Math FREE Sample Practice Questions




What people say about "Rule of Four: How the Supreme Court Picks Its Cases"?
No one replied yet.