Monty Hall Problem: Why Switching Wins 2/3 of the Time

Quick answer: In the Monty Hall problem, you pick one of three doors; one hides a car and two hide goats. The host, who knows where the car is, opens a different door showing a goat and offers you a switch. You should switch: switching wins with probability 2/3, staying wins with probability 1/3. Your first pick is right only 1/3 of the time, and the host’s reveal does not change that.

Few puzzles have caused as many arguments as this one. In 1990, Marilyn vos Savant answered it in her Parade magazine column, and thousands of readers, including many with PhDs, wrote in to tell her she was wrong. She was right. Here is why, in a way you can check yourself.

The Setup

  1. There are three closed doors. Behind one is a car; behind the other two are goats.
  2. You pick a door, say Door 1.
  3. The host, who knows what is behind every door, opens one of the other two doors, always revealing a goat.
  4. He offers you the chance to switch to the remaining closed door. Should you?

The answer depends on these rules, especially that the host always opens a goat door and always offers the switch. When both unchosen doors hide goats, assume he picks between them at random.

Every Case in One Table

Suppose you pick Door 1. Each row is an initial car location, with probability \(\frac13\):

Car behindHost opensStay wins?Switch wins?
Door 1Door 2 or 3YesNo
Door 2Door 3NoYes
Door 3Door 2NoYes

Staying wins in 1 of 3 equally likely cases; switching wins in 2 of 3. So

\[ P(\text{win by staying}) = \frac{1}{3}, \qquad P(\text{win by switching}) = \frac{2}{3}. \]

Learn more about how to calculate probability.

The 100-Door Trick

Imagine 100 doors. You pick one. The host, who knows where the car is, opens 98 of the 99 doors you did not pick, all goats, leaving just your door and one other closed. Would you stick with your original 1-in-100 guess? Your first pick is right only 1% of the time, so the other door has the car 99% of the time. Three doors work the same way, just less dramatically: 1/3 versus 2/3.

Why Intuition Says 50/50

Once two doors remain, it feels like each must be 50/50. The mistake is ignoring how the host chose. He is not random: he must avoid the car and avoid your door. When you picked a goat (probability 2/3), he is forced to leave the car behind the other door. His choice carries information. In the language of conditional probability (Bayes’ theorem), and assuming the host picks randomly between two goat doors when he can, the probability the car is behind Door 1, given that he opened Door 3, is still \(1/3\). Whatever his tie-breaking habit, the strategy “always switch” wins \(2/3\) of all games.

When the Answer Changes

Host behaviorBest choice
Always opens a goat door and offers a switch (standard)Switch: 2/3
Does not know where the car is and opens an unchosen door at random; counting only games where a goat appearsEither: 1/2
Offers a switch only when your first pick is the car; counting only games with an offerStay: switching always loses

Many of the 1990 arguments were really about which rules were assumed.

A Famous Argument

Statistician Steve Selvin posed the puzzle in two 1975 letters to The American Statistician, as a mathematical model inspired by Monty Hall’s TV show Let’s Make a Deal (the real show did not always follow these rules). After vos Savant’s column, she estimated about 10,000 letters, mostly disagreeing, with close to 1,000 signed by people with PhDs. Even Paul Erdős was reportedly unconvinced at first; according to Andrew Vázsonyi, a computer simulation helped him accept the answer, and Ron Graham later gave him an explanation he found satisfying. Our quiz below lets you test yourself.

Common Misconceptions

“Two doors left means 50/50.” Only if the host acted randomly. Under the standard rules, the host’s knowledge makes switching better.

“Switching guarantees the car.” No. It wins 2 out of 3 times on average; you still lose 1 time in 3.

Watch: The Monty Hall Problem in Video

If you learn better by watching, these videos are worth your time.

Monty Hall Problem – Numberphile (Numberphile). The classic explanation with Lisa Goldberg.
Monty Hall Problem (best explanation) – Numberphile (Numberphile). A second, very clear take on why switching wins.
The Monty Hall Problem – Explained (AsapSCIENCE). A quick animated explanation.

Check Your Understanding

Five quick questions to see how much of this has stuck. Pick an answer and press Submit; you will see a short explanation either way.

Answer each question and press Submit to see your result right away.

1. In the standard Monty Hall problem, what is your chance of winning if you switch?
Found a bug? Let us know!
2. What is your chance of winning if you stay?
Found a bug? Let us know!
3. With 100 doors and the host opening 98 goat doors, what is the chance the other door has the car?
Found a bug? Let us know!
4. If the host does not know where the car is, opens a door at random, and it happens to show a goat, what is the chance switching wins?
Found a bug? Let us know!
5. Who made the problem famous in a 1990 magazine column?
Found a bug? Let us know!

Frequently Asked Questions

Should you switch in the Monty Hall problem?

Yes. Under the standard rules, switching wins with probability 2/3 and staying wins with probability 1/3.

Why is the Monty Hall answer not 50/50?

Because the host knows where the car is and always opens a goat door. When your first pick is a goat, which happens 2/3 of the time, the host is forced to leave the car behind the other door.

Who invented the Monty Hall problem?

Statistician Steve Selvin posed it in 1975. It became famous after Marilyn vos Savant answered it in Parade magazine in 1990.

Does the Monty Hall answer change if the host opens a door at random?

Yes. If the host does not know where the car is, opens a random unchosen door, and it happens to show a goat, switching and staying each win with probability 1/2.

Keep Exploring

Sources and Further Reading

Related to This Article

What people say about "Monty Hall Problem: Why Switching Wins 2/3 of the Time - Effortless Math"?

No one replied yet.

Leave a Reply