Banach–Tarski Paradox: How One Ball Becomes Two

Quick answer: The Banach–Tarski paradox is a theorem, proved by Stefan Banach and Alfred Tarski in 1924, that a solid ball can be split into finitely many pieces, as few as five, that can be moved by rotations and translations and reassembled into two balls identical to the original. It does not violate physics because the partition includes non-measurable sets, to which ordinary volume does not apply, and the standard proof uses the axiom of choice.

Take a solid ball. Cut it into five pieces. Move the pieces around without stretching or bending them, and reassemble them into two solid balls, each exactly the same size as the original. This sounds like a con, but it is a proved theorem of mathematics. The catch is in what “pieces” means.

The Statement

In 1924, Stefan Banach and Alfred Tarski proved that a solid ball in three-dimensional space can be decomposed into finitely many disjoint pieces which, after only rotations and translations (rigid motions), form two balls of the same size as the original. In 1947, Raphael Robinson showed that for a solid ball five pieces suffice and four do not (four suffice for the ball without its center, or for the spherical surface alone).

Volume should be preserved by rigid motions: the volume of a sphere is \(\frac43 \pi r^3\), so how can one ball become two? The answer is that some pieces are non-measurable: ordinary volume does not apply to them. That does not mean zero or infinite volume; it means the volume rule cannot be extended to every possible set of points.

The Algebraic Idea Behind the Proof

Choose two carefully selected rotations of the ball, \(a\) and \(b\), for example by the angle \(\arccos\frac13\) about the perpendicular \(x\)- and \(z\)-axes. Every combination, like \(a b a^{-1} b\), is a different rotation; nothing ever cancels unexpectedly. Mathematicians call this a free group.

Sort all these reduced “words” by their first letter: those starting with \(a\), \(a^{-1}\), \(b\) and \(b^{-1}\). These four sets cover everything except the empty word, which the full proof handles separately. Here is the twist: take the words starting with \(a^{-1}\) and put \(a\) in front. The \(a\) cancels the leading \(a^{-1}\), and the result is every word that does not start with \(a\). So

\[ F = W(a) \cup a\,W(a^{-1}), \qquad F = W(b) \cup b\,W(b^{-1}). \]

Two of the four pieces rebuild the whole group, and the other two rebuild it again. One group becomes two copies of itself. This is the idea behind Felix Hausdorff’s 1914 paradox. The geometric proof also has to deal with points fixed by the rotations, orbit representatives and the ball’s center.

Ingredient 2: The Axiom of Choice

To move this paradox from the rotation group onto points of the ball, you sort the ball’s points into orbits (all the places a point can reach by these rotations) and pick one representative point from each orbit. There are uncountably many orbits and no rule for which point to pick. The axiom of choice, a standard axiom of set theory, says such a choice is possible anyway. The resulting pieces are wildly scattered sets of points, not anything you could cut with a knife.

Why It Does Not Break Physics

  • The pieces are non-measurable: they have no well-defined volume, so “volume is preserved” does not apply to them.
  • Real objects are made of finitely many atoms; you cannot split a physical ball into infinitely scattered point sets.
  • In two dimensions, a disk cannot be duplicated using finitely many pieces moved only by rotations and translations (Banach, 1923), because the rotation group of the plane is too simple.

Common Misconceptions

“It is a trick or an error.” No. It is a rigorous theorem in standard set theory (ZFC). It cannot be proved in ZF without some choice principle, although a weaker principle than the full axiom of choice is enough.

“You could duplicate gold with it.” No. The pieces cannot exist physically, and they have no volume or mass in any meaningful sense.

“It means the axiom of choice is false.” Most mathematicians accept the axiom of choice; Banach–Tarski is seen as a surprising but harmless consequence. It is related to the debates around the continuum hypothesis and other questions about infinity.

Watch: The Banach–Tarski Paradox in Video

If you learn better by watching, these videos are worth your time.

The Banach–Tarski Paradox (Vsauce). The most famous visual explanation, including the free group trick.
The Most Controversial Idea In Math (Veritasium). The axiom of choice and why Banach–Tarski depends on it.
Does math have a major flaw? (TED-Ed). A short animated introduction.

Check Your Understanding

Five quick questions to see how much of this has stuck. Pick an answer and press Submit; you will see a short explanation either way.

Answer each question and press Submit to see your result right away.

1. What is the minimum number of pieces needed for the Banach–Tarski paradox?
Found a bug? Let us know!
2. Which axiom does the Banach–Tarski paradox rely on?
Found a bug? Let us know!
3. Why does volume not seem to be preserved?
Found a bug? Let us know!
4. Does an analogous paradox work for a disk in the plane?
Found a bug? Let us know!
5. When was the Banach–Tarski paradox published?
Found a bug? Let us know!

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the Banach–Tarski paradox in simple terms?

It is a theorem saying a solid ball can be cut into finitely many pieces (five suffice) that can be rearranged, using only rotations and moves, into two balls the same size as the original.

Is the Banach–Tarski paradox real?

It is a proved theorem in standard mathematics (ZFC set theory). It cannot be done with physical objects, because the pieces are non-measurable point sets.

Why does Banach–Tarski need the axiom of choice?

The construction picks one point from each of uncountably many orbits with no rule for choosing. The axiom of choice is what guarantees such a selection exists.

How many pieces does Banach–Tarski need?

Five pieces are enough, and four are not, as Raphael Robinson proved in 1947.

Keep Exploring

Sources and Further Reading

Related to This Article

What people say about "Banach–Tarski Paradox: How One Ball Becomes Two - Effortless Math"?

No one replied yet.

Leave a Reply