Einstein Tile Explained: Hat, Spectre and 3D Chair44
Quick answer: An einstein tile is a single shape that can cover the entire plane without gaps or overlaps, but cannot form any tiling that repeats under a nonzero translation. The hat, announced in 2023, needs both ordinary and mirror-image copies. The spectre forces tilings of a single handedness. The name comes from the German ein Stein, “one stone.” In September 2026, a 3D candidate called Chair44 was announced in a preprint.
An ordinary square can tile a floor in a repeating grid. The challenge was to find one shape for which every possible tiling is nonperiodic. A picture of one unusual arrangement is not enough: mathematicians had to rule out every repeating arrangement across the infinite plane. The answer came from an unexpected place: a retired print technician in England playing with shapes on his computer.
What Is an Einstein Tile?
A tiling is periodic if some nonzero translation, a slide by a fixed distance and direction, maps the entire infinite tiling onto itself. An aperiodic monotile, or einstein, is one shape that can cover the plane, but none of its tilings has such a translation. Small groups of tiles may appear again and again; what cannot repeat is the whole arrangement under a single slide. The name is a pun on “ein Stein,” German for “one stone,” not a reference to Albert Einstein.
| Year | Discovery | Tile types and constraints |
|---|---|---|
| 1966 | Robert Berger’s first aperiodic set | 20,426 colored Wang tiles |
| 1970s | Penrose tiles (kite and dart) | 2 shapes plus matching rules |
| 2023 (March) | The hat | 1 shape; tilings use mirror images |
| 2023 (May) | The spectre | 1 shape; tilings use one handedness |
| 2026 (September) | Chair44, a 3D candidate (preprint) | 1 shape with bumps and dents on its faces |
The Hat
In November 2022, David Smith noticed that a 13-sided shape he had made from eight kites cut from a hexagonal grid seemed to tile the plane without ever repeating. He contacted Craig Kaplan, a computer scientist at the University of Waterloo, and with Joseph Samuel Myers and Chaim Goodman-Strauss they proved it in a paper posted in March 2023 and published in Combinatorial Theory in 2024. The hat was the first single connected polygon shown to force aperiodicity through its shape alone.
The hat has one catch: every hat tiling uses some mirror-image copies, a small minority of the tiles. If you count a tile and its reflection as the same shape, the hat is a true einstein. Some mathematicians wanted more.
How do you prove something about an infinite floor? The authors showed that hats must always group into larger “supertiles,” which group into still larger ones, forever. A hierarchy like that cannot be periodic. A big computer picture alone could never prove it, because it shows only a finite patch.
The Spectre
Two months later, the same team found the spectre. Its relative, the equal-edged polygon called Tile(1,1), can form periodic tilings if reflections are allowed. The spectre modifies the edges so that every valid tiling uses only one handedness, even when mirror copies are allowed in principle, and every tiling is nonperiodic. The spectre paper was also published in Combinatorial Theory in 2024.
| Feature | Hat | Spectre | Chair44 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Space tiled | 2D plane | 2D plane | 3D space |
| Shape | 13-sided polygon | Modified edges | Seven-cube chair with surface bumps and dents |
| Reflections | Tilings need both handednesses | Tilings use one handedness | Each tiling uses one handedness |
| Status | Journal paper, 2024 | Journal paper, 2024 | 2026 preprint |
Into Three Dimensions: Chair44
In 3D, the Schmitt–Conway–Danzer tile cannot tile space periodically, but its tilings can keep an infinite-order screw (twisting) symmetry, so it is only weakly aperiodic.
On September 16, 2026, software developer Ioannis Tsiokos posted a preprint describing Chair44, based on a 2×2×2 block with one corner cube removed. Small bumps and dents on its faces enforce matching rules that force copies into larger chair-shaped clusters, which form still larger clusters. The surface features are essential: the plain seven-cube chair can tile space periodically.
Chair44 is described as strongly aperiodic: its tilings have no translational period or any other symmetry of infinite order. That does not mean no symmetry at all; the theorem allows a finite symmetry group of order at most 24. Tsiokos credited AI assistance for the discovery. Felix Flicker of the University of Bristol posted simpler matching rules on September 20, and Chaim Goodman-Strauss posted a clear human-written explanation of the proof the next day (revised in October). The original manuscript is still labeled an unrefereed preprint. In a guest post on Terence Tao’s blog, Kate Stange and Edmund Harriss used Chair44 as an example of how mathematicians “digest” AI-found results.
Why It Matters Beyond Floors
Non-repeating order shows up in quasicrystals, a discovery that won Dan Shechtman the 2011 Nobel Prize in Chemistry. In 2026, researchers at the University of Tokyo built nanoscale structures based on hat tilings; under laser light they produced chiral, pinwheel-like diffraction patterns. The experiment opens new directions for studying how aperiodic order affects light; practical devices are a question for future research.
Try It Yourself
Print a sheet of hat outlines (the discoverers provide free outlines and an online generator), cut out a dozen, and grow a patch. Find a reflected hat. Then ask: does your patch prove the tiling never repeats? It does not, which is exactly why the supertile proof was needed.
Common Misconceptions
“Einstein tiles are named after Albert Einstein.” No, the name means “one stone” in German.
“Aperiodic means random.” No. The patterns are highly ordered, built from nested supertiles, but no slide maps the whole tiling onto itself.
Watch: The Einstein Tile in Video
If you learn better by watching, these videos are worth your time.
Check Your Understanding
Five quick questions to see how much of this has stuck. Pick an answer and press Submit; you will see a short explanation either way.
Answer each question and press Submit to see your result right away.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is an einstein tile?
An einstein tile, or aperiodic monotile, is a single shape that can cover the entire plane without gaps or overlaps, but only in patterns that never repeat.
Who discovered the hat tile?
David Smith, a retired print technician from England, found it in 2022. He proved it aperiodic with Joseph Samuel Myers, Craig Kaplan and Chaim Goodman-Strauss in a paper posted in March 2023.
Does the hat tile need reflections?
Yes. Every tiling by the hat uses some mirror-image copies. The spectre, found in May 2023, avoids reflections entirely.
Is there a 3D einstein tile?
A strong candidate was announced in September 2026: Chair44, a seven-cube chair with bumps and dents on its faces, claimed to tile space only without any translational or other infinite-order symmetry. Ioannis Tsiokos found it with AI assistance; Felix Flicker and Chaim Goodman-Strauss posted simpler rules and a clear explanation. The original paper is an unrefereed preprint.
Can small patterns repeat in an einstein tiling?
Yes. Small groups of tiles recur throughout the tiling. What cannot happen is a single slide that maps the entire infinite tiling onto itself.
Keep Exploring
- Noperthedron: Why This Shape Can’t Pass Through Itself
- Four Color Theorem: What the 2026 Proof Changes
- Moving Sofa Problem Solved: Why Gerver’s Sofa Wins
Sources and Further Reading
- Smith, Myers, Kaplan and Goodman-Strauss, An aperiodic monotile (arXiv 2303.10798)
- Quanta Magazine: Hobbyist Finds Math’s Elusive Einstein Tile (April 4, 2023)
- University of Waterloo: The vampire einstein (the spectre)
- Ioannis Tsiokos, Chair44 (arXiv 2609.19214)
- Chaim Goodman-Strauss, proof for Chair44 (arXiv 2609.24779)
- Felix Flicker, matching rules for Chair44 (arXiv 2609.23783)
- Craig Kaplan: An aperiodic monotile (hat project page)
- Terence Tao’s blog: Illustration beyond proof (Oct 11, 2026)
- ScienceDaily: The shape behind the Einstein problem revealed new physics (Sept 2026)
Related to This Article
More math articles
- Samples, Populations, and Bias
- ASVAB Shop Information Study Guide: A 28-Lesson Roadmap
- The Ultimate PEAKS Algebra 1 Course (+FREE Worksheets)
- The Best Grade 8 ELA Practice Tests for Wyoming Students
- Grade 5 Math Flashcards (Free Online: Formulas, Terms & Concepts)
- How to Solve Powers of Products and Quotients? (+FREE Worksheet!)
- Free Grade 6 English Worksheets for Vermont Students
- The Best Grade 8 ELA Practice Tests for Wisconsin Students
- Populations, Communities and Biomes: Compare Ecology Levels
- HiSET Passing Score: What You Need on Each Subtest and in Total


What people say about "Einstein Tile Explained: Hat, Spectre and 3D Chair44 - Effortless Math"?
No one replied yet.