Prisoner’s Dilemma Explained: Payoff Table & Examples
Quick answer: In the prisoner’s dilemma, two suspects are questioned separately. If both stay silent, each gets 1 year; if both confess, each gets 3 years; if one confesses and the other stays silent, the confessor goes free and the other gets 5 years. Confessing is better for each person whatever the other does, so both confess and get 3 years, even though both staying silent (1 year each) is better for both. Mutual confession is the Nash equilibrium. It shows why individual logic can defeat cooperation, and how repeated play can change the outcome.
Two people who would both be better off cooperating end up hurting each other, not from malice but from cold logic. That is the prisoner’s dilemma, the most famous puzzle in game theory. It explains price wars, arms races, climate negotiations and even why some animals cooperate.
The Story and the Payoffs
Two suspects, A and B, are held in separate rooms. Each can stay silent (cooperate with the partner) or confess (defect). The standard model assumes each wants the shortest sentence for themselves, chooses without seeing the other’s choice, and cannot make a binding deal. Years in prison (lower is better):
| B stays silent | B confesses | |
|---|---|---|
| A stays silent | A: 1, B: 1 | A: 5, B: 0 |
| A confesses | A: 0, B: 5 | A: 3, B: 3 |
Read the table one player at a time (see how to read a payoff matrix).
Why Both Confess
Think as A:
- If B stays silent: confessing gives 0 years instead of 1. Better to confess.
- If B confesses: confessing gives 3 years instead of 5. Better to confess.
Whatever B does, confessing gives A a shorter sentence. So confessing is a strictly dominant strategy. B reasons the same way, and both confess, each serving 3 years.
A Nash Equilibrium Example
Mutual confession is the Nash equilibrium: if B confesses, A switching to silence would raise A’s sentence from 3 to 5 years, and the same holds for B. Neither can do better by changing alone. Yet both staying silent (1 year each) is better for both. That is the lesson: an equilibrium does not have to be the outcome everyone prefers. Individual rationality leads to a worse group result.
| Idea | Meaning here |
|---|---|
| Dominant strategy | Confess is best for you whatever the other does |
| Nash equilibrium | Both confess; nobody gains by switching alone |
| Better joint outcome | Both silent, 1 year each, but each is tempted to switch |
Playing Again and Again
Real life is rarely one-shot. In the iterated prisoner’s dilemma, the same players meet many times. In computer tournaments reported in 1980, political scientist Robert Axelrod had strategies submitted by experts play each other repeatedly. The winner was the simplest: Tit for Tat, submitted by Anatol Rapoport, which cooperates first, then copies the opponent’s last move.
Successful strategies shared four traits: be nice (never defect first), retaliate, forgive, and be clear. Repetition can make cooperation pay when the future matters enough, because betrayal today costs you tomorrow. If the number of rounds is fixed and known in advance, though, backward reasoning in the standard model (like in the unexpected hanging paradox) predicts defection in every round, which real players often ignore.
Does Tit for Tat always win? No. It won Axelrod’s tournaments, but it is not the best strategy in every setting. When moves are sometimes misread or mistakes happen, two Tit for Tat players can fall into long cycles of revenge, and more forgiving variants often do better. Results depend on which other strategies are in the pool.
Real-World Examples
- Price wars: two shops both cut prices and both earn less. (Real situations only follow the prisoner’s dilemma when the payoffs have this same structure.)
- Arms races: each country arms for safety, and both end up poorer and no safer.
- Climate and fishing: each nation gains by polluting or overfishing while others restrain, so the shared resource suffers (a “tragedy of the commons”).
- Traffic: selfish route choices can make everyone slower, as in Braess’s paradox.
History
Merrill Flood and Melvin Dresher studied the game at the RAND Corporation in 1950. Albert Tucker supplied the familiar story about two prisoners while presenting it to an audience of psychologists.
Common Misconceptions
“The prisoners are just being selfish or stupid.” No. Confessing is the logically best individual choice; the dilemma is that it produces a worse joint outcome.
“Cooperation never happens.” It often does, through repetition, reputation, contracts or trust, which change the game.
Watch: The Prisoner’s Dilemma in Video
If you learn better by watching, these videos are worth your time.
Check Your Understanding
Five quick questions to see how much of this has stuck. Pick an answer and press Submit; you will see a short explanation either way.
Answer each question and press Submit to see your result right away.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the prisoner’s dilemma in simple terms?
A game where two players each do better by betraying the other, whatever the other does, yet both end up worse off than if they had cooperated.
Why is confessing the dominant strategy?
Because it gives a shorter sentence whether the other prisoner stays silent (0 vs 1 year) or confesses (3 vs 5 years).
How can cooperation win in the prisoner’s dilemma?
When the game is repeated and the future matters enough, strategies like Tit for Tat reward cooperation and punish betrayal, making cooperation pay over time.
What is the Nash equilibrium in the prisoner’s dilemma?
Both prisoners confess. If either one switched alone to staying silent, that prisoner would get a longer sentence, so neither has a reason to change, even though both staying silent would be better for both.
What are real-world examples of the prisoner’s dilemma?
Price wars, arms races, overfishing, climate agreements and doping in sports.
Keep Exploring
- Braess’s Paradox: Why New Roads Can Slow Traffic
- Newcomb’s Paradox Explained: One Box or Two?
- Unexpected Hanging Paradox: The Surprise Exam Explained
Sources and Further Reading
Related to This Article
More math articles
- The Best Grade 4 ELA Practice Tests for South Carolina Students
- How to Using Decimals, Grid Models, and Fractions to Represent Percent
- Free Grade 8 English Worksheets for New York Students
- FREE 4th Grade Common Core Math Practice Test
- The Best Grade 4 ELA Practice Tests for Indiana Students
- Holds
- Free Grade 6 English Worksheets for Nevada Students
- 10 PSAT/NMSQT Math Practice Questions with Explanations
- How to Use the Graphs of System of Equations for Classification
- The Best Grade 6 ELA Practice Tests for New Hampshire Students


What people say about "Prisoner’s Dilemma Explained: Payoff Table & Examples - Effortless Math"?
No one replied yet.