Braess’s Paradox: Why New Roads Can Slow Traffic

Quick answer: Braess’s paradox, described by Dietrich Braess in 1968, says that adding a new road to a congested network can make every driver’s trip slower. Each driver picks the fastest route for themselves, and the new shortcut lures everyone onto the same busy links. In the standard teaching example, adding a zero-travel-time connector raises everyone’s travel time from 65 to 80 minutes. Related effects appear in power grids and mechanical networks.

When traffic is bad, the obvious fix is to build another road. Surprisingly, that can make things worse for everyone, even when nobody does anything foolish. German mathematician Dietrich Braess showed this in 1968, and the effect has since been seen in real cities.

A Worked Example (Standard Teaching Model)

4,000 drivers travel from Start to End every morning. There are two routes, each made of one “busy” road and one “wide” road:

  • Busy roads take \(\frac{T}{100}\) minutes, where \(T\) is the number of cars on them.
  • Wide roads always take 45 minutes.

Route 1 is Start → A (busy) → End (wide). Route 2 is Start → B (wide) → End (busy).

The drivers split evenly, 2,000 per route. Each trip takes

\[ \frac{2000}{100} + 45 = 20 + 45 = 65 \text{ minutes}. \]

Now Add a Shortcut

The city builds a link from A to B that, in this simplified model, takes 0 minutes. Now a driver can go Start → A (busy) → B → End (busy). Look at it from one driver’s point of view: each busy road takes at most \(\frac{4000}{100} = 40\) minutes, which beats the 45-minute wide road. So every driver switches to the busy-busy route. With all 4,000 cars on both busy roads:

\[ \frac{4000}{100} + \frac{4000}{100} = 40 + 40 = 80 \text{ minutes}. \]

NetworkEach driver’s trip
Without the shortcut65 minutes
With the zero-time connector80 minutes

No single driver can do better by switching back: an old route would now take \(40 + 45 = 85\) minutes. Everyone is stuck in a worse situation, a Nash equilibrium that is not the best outcome for the group.

Why It Happens

Each driver chooses selfishly, ignoring the delay their car adds for others. The connector itself never slows down; instead, the two existing busy roads each end up carrying all 4,000 cars. By analogy with the prisoner’s dilemma, choices that are best for each individual add up to a worse result for the group.

Real-World Examples

  • Seoul, South Korea: removing an elevated highway to restore the Cheonggyecheon stream (2003 to 2005) did not cause the feared gridlock; studies found travelers adapted, with more subway use and fewer car trips, though speeds and volumes on nearby roads changed in mixed ways. It shows how travel adapts after a road is removed, rather than cleanly proving Braess’s paradox.
  • New York City: a reported example often linked to the paradox: when 42nd Street was closed for Earth Day in 1990, traffic in the area was said to flow better than usual.
  • Power grids: a 2022 Nature Communications study showed in lab experiments and grid models that adding or strengthening a line can overload other parts of an electrical network, a related network effect governed by physical laws rather than choices.

Common Misconceptions

“Adding roads always makes traffic worse.” No. Braess’s paradox only happens in particular networks and traffic levels. Often new capacity helps.

“The drivers are being irrational.” No. Each driver makes the best choice for themselves; the problem is the lack of coordination.

Watch: Braess’s Paradox in Video

If you learn better by watching, these videos are worth your time.

Braess’s Paradox – Equilibria Gone Wild (Up and Atom). A clear explanation with traffic and springs.
The Braess Paradox: How Closing Roads Can Speed Up Traffic (MindYourDecisions). A worked example step by step.

Check Your Understanding

Five quick questions to see how much of this has stuck. Pick an answer and press Submit; you will see a short explanation either way.

Answer each question and press Submit to see your result right away.

1. Before the connector, how long does each trip take in the example?
Found a bug? Let us know!
2. After the zero-time connector is added, how long does each trip take?
Found a bug? Let us know!
3. Why do drivers all switch to the shortcut route?
Found a bug? Let us know!
4. What is the final situation called in game theory?
Found a bug? Let us know!
5. Who described this paradox in 1968?
Found a bug? Let us know!

Frequently Asked Questions

What is Braess’s paradox?

The surprising fact that adding a road to a congested network can make every driver’s trip longer, because selfish route choices lead everyone onto the same busy links.

Why does a new road make traffic worse in Braess’s paradox?

Each driver switches to the route that looks fastest for them, but when all do, the shared roads clog and everyone ends up slower.

Is Braess’s paradox real?

Yes. It follows from simple traffic models and has been observed in cases such as Seoul’s Cheonggyecheon highway removal, as well as in physical systems like springs and power grids.

Who discovered Braess’s paradox?

German mathematician Dietrich Braess published it in 1968.

Keep Exploring

Sources and Further Reading

Related to This Article

What people say about "Braess’s Paradox: Why New Roads Can Slow Traffic - Effortless Math"?

No one replied yet.

Leave a Reply