8 Amateur Math Discoveries That Changed Mathematics

Quick answer: Yes, amateur mathematicians have made important discoveries without holding academic positions. Marjorie Rice found four new types of pentagons that tile the plane in 1976 and 1977. In 2022, retired print technician David Smith discovered the hat, a single shape that tiles the plane only without repeating. Other examples include an anonymous 4chan poster’s superpermutation bound (2011), Aubrey de Grey’s proof that the plane needs at least 5 colors (2018) and Luke Durant’s 41,024,320-digit prime (2024).

Facts checked November 22, 2026.

Mathematics has no entrance exam. A proof is a proof whether it comes from a professor, a homemaker or an anonymous stranger online. Some of the most delightful discoveries of the past 50 years came from people with no academic position, working at kitchen tables, on hobby forums or with spare computer time. Here are eight of them, and what their stories mean now that AI tools are widely available.

At a Glance

WhoDay jobYearDiscovery
Pierre de FermatLawyer1600sFoundations of number theory and probability
Marjorie RiceHomemaker1976–1977New types of pentagons that tile the plane
Anonymous 4chan posterUnknown2011Lower bound for superpermutations
Aubrey de GreyBiologist2018The plane needs at least 5 colors
David SmithRetired print technician2022–2023The hat, the first einstein tile
Luke DurantFormer Nvidia engineer2024The largest known prime
mxdys and the Busy Beaver ChallengePseudonymous contributor and online volunteers2024–2025\(BB(5)\) and record \(BB(6)\) bounds
AI-assisted contributorsVarious2026Erdős problems solved with AI tools

1. Pierre de Fermat: The Original Amateur

Fermat was a lawyer and magistrate in Toulouse who did mathematics in his spare time. Through letters with other scholars he helped found probability theory (with Blaise Pascal) and modern number theory. His note in the margin of a book, claiming a proof too large to fit, became Fermat’s Last Theorem, finally proved by Andrew Wiles in 1995.

2. Marjorie Rice: Pentagons at the Kitchen Table

Which pentagons can tile a floor with no gaps? In 1975, Martin Gardner wrote in Scientific American about the types then known. Marjorie Rice, a San Diego homemaker with no formal math training beyond high school, read it and invented her own notation. By February 1976 she had found her first new type, and by late 1977 she had discovered four new types of tiling pentagons, which mathematician Doris Schattschneider verified and publicized. In 2017, Michaël Rao announced a computer-assisted proof that the list of 15 types is complete.

3. The Anonymous 4chan Proof

On September 16, 2011, an anime fan on the 4chan message board asked: what is the shortest sequence of episodes that contains every possible viewing order of a show? Within an hour, an anonymous poster gave a clever lower bound for these “superpermutations.” Years later, mathematicians checked the argument, found it correct and, in 2018, wrote it up formally, crediting “Anonymous 4chan poster” as an author.

4. Aubrey de Grey: Five Colors for the Plane

How many colors are needed so that no two points exactly 1 unit apart share a color? For 68 years the answer was known to be 4, 5, 6 or 7. In 2018, Aubrey de Grey, a biologist known for research on aging, built a 1,581-point graph showing that 4 colors are not enough. His result started a Polymath project that shrank the graph further. In October 2026, an OpenAI paper claimed a proof that the plane cannot be colored with 5 colors, which would make the answer 6 or 7; de Grey’s 2018 result remains the landmark that reopened the problem; see unsolved problems AI could solve next.

5. David Smith: The Hat Tile

For decades mathematicians asked whether a single tile could cover the plane without ever repeating, an “einstein” (from the German for “one stone”). In late 2022, David Smith, a retired print technician from England who enjoyed playing with shapes, found a 13-sided tile that seemed to work. He contacted mathematicians, and in March 2023 Smith, Joseph Samuel Myers, Craig Kaplan and Chaim Goodman-Strauss announced the “hat,” proving it is an aperiodic monotile (the paper was published in 2024).

TileYearKey feature
The hat2022–2023Tiles only without repeating, but needs some mirror-image copies
The spectre2023Same team; tiles without repeating using no mirror images at all

See the einstein tile explained.

6. Luke Durant: The Largest Known Prime

On October 12, 2024, Luke Durant, a former Nvidia engineer and volunteer in the Great Internet Mersenne Prime Search, proved that \(2^{136{,}279{,}841} – 1\) is prime. With 41,024,320 digits, it is the largest prime known, and it ended a 28-year run of records found on ordinary PCs, because Durant used thousands of cloud GPUs. See the largest known prime number.

7. The Busy Beaver Challenge

The Busy Beaver Challenge, an online collaboration started in 2022, proved in 2024 that \(S(5) = 47{,}176{,}870\): the longest any halting five-state, two-symbol Turing machine can run from a blank tape. The whole proof was checked in the Coq proof assistant. A key contributor, known only as mxdys, then found six-state machines in June 2025 that pushed the known lower bound for six states to unimaginable sizes; the exact six-state value remains unknown. See what is the biggest number?

8. AI-Assisted Contributors in 2026: A Case Study

In January 2026, Kevin Barreto used GPT-5.2 Pro on Erdős Problem 728, and Harmonic’s Aristotle system produced a Lean proof of the intended statement. We are not claiming Barreto is an amateur; the point is that AI tools and public trackers of Erdős problems now let a much wider circle of people, professional or not, contribute and check results. AI tools lower the barrier to entry, but the community still demands clear statements and verified proofs. See Erdős problems solved by AI.

What Amateurs Do Well

  • Fresh eyes: Rice and Smith approached problems without assumptions about what would not work.
  • Persistence: hobbyists can spend years on one question with no deadline.
  • Computation: spare computer time and clever code power prime searches and Busy Beaver proofs.
  • Collaboration: nearly every story involves a professional who checked and helped publish the work.

How to Contribute as an Amateur

  1. Pick concrete problems with checkable answers, such as tilings, puzzles or computational searches.
  2. Join a community: GIMPS, the Busy Beaver Challenge, the Erdős problems site and math forums welcome newcomers.
  3. Write it down carefully and contact a mathematician who works in the area.
  4. Use AI and proof checkers wisely: they can suggest ideas and verify steps, but you must understand and check the result.

Common Misconceptions

“You need a PhD to discover anything.” Every story above says otherwise.

“Amateur discoveries are always lucky accidents.” Most came from long, careful work.

“If I think I proved a famous conjecture, I probably did.” Famous problems attract many flawed proofs. Start with smaller questions, and seek expert feedback before announcing.

Watch: Amateurs Who Changed Math

If you learn better by watching, these videos are worth your time.

How a Hobbyist Solved a 50-Year-Old Math Problem (Einstein Tile) (Up and Atom). How David Smith found the hat tile and why it matters.
Doris Schattschneider – Marjorie Rice’s pursuit of convex pentagon tilers (G4G Celebration). The mathematician who verified Marjorie Rice’s discoveries tells her story.

Check Your Understanding

Five quick questions to see how much of this has stuck. Pick an answer and press Submit; you will see a short explanation either way.

Answer each question and press Submit to see your result right away.

1. What did David Smith discover?
Found a bug? Let us know!
2. What was Marjorie Rice’s job?
Found a bug? Let us know!
3. How many digits does the prime Luke Durant found have?
Found a bug? Let us know!
4. What did Aubrey de Grey show in 2018?
Found a bug? Let us know!
5. What is Pierre de Fermat famous for besides mathematics?
Found a bug? Let us know!

Frequently Asked Questions

Have amateur mathematicians made real discoveries?

Yes. Examples include Marjorie Rice’s pentagon tilings, the anonymous 4chan superpermutation bound, Aubrey de Grey’s 2018 coloring result, David Smith’s hat tile and Luke Durant’s 2024 largest known prime.

Who discovered the einstein hat tile?

David Smith, a retired print technician, found it in 2022. He announced it in March 2023 with mathematicians Joseph Samuel Myers, Craig Kaplan and Chaim Goodman-Strauss.

Who found the largest known prime?

Luke Durant, a former Nvidia engineer and GIMPS volunteer, proved that 2^136,279,841 − 1 is prime on October 12, 2024.

Can amateurs still make math discoveries today?

Yes. Computational projects, online problem trackers and AI tools make it easier than ever, though results must still be carefully proved and checked.

How should an amateur share a math discovery?

Write the argument carefully, check small cases, and contact a mathematician who works in that area before announcing it publicly.

Keep Exploring

Sources and Further Reading

Related to This Article

What people say about "8 Amateur Math Discoveries That Changed Mathematics - Effortless Math"?

No one replied yet.

Leave a Reply