YOUR CLEP STUDY COMPANION
Presidential vs. Congressional Reconstruction: Plans Compared
Compare Presidential and Congressional Reconstruction through pardons, readmission conditions, Black male suffrage and federal authority. Read the original policies and try the lesson practice.
Presidential and Congressional Reconstruction differed over who would direct restoration and what protections southern governments had to provide. Compare Johnson’s pardon policy with Congress’s requirements for new constitutions, Black male suffrage and Fourteenth Amendment ratification. This CLEP U.S. History I lesson focuses on institutions and conditions, not just a contrast between leniency and severity.
U.S. History to 1877 | Chapter 19 | Lesson 19.1
Lincoln, Johnson and Presidential Restoration
Lincoln’s wartime plans emphasized quick restoration with a loyal minority, though his final position was still developing when he was assassinated. Andrew Johnson offered broad pardons and allowed southern states to reorganize with limited federal demands beyond ending slavery, repudiating Confederate debt, and renouncing secession. Those governments enacted Black Codes and elected prominent former Confederates, convincing many Republicans that restoration without stronger federal protection would preserve the old ruling class.
Congressional Reconstruction and Readmission
Congress refused to accept the process on Johnson’s terms. It investigated conditions, renewed the Freedmen’s Bureau, enacted the Civil Rights Act of 1866 over Johnson’s veto, proposed the Fourteenth Amendment, and passed Reconstruction Acts placing ten unreconstructed states under military administration. New conventions had to provide Black male suffrage, and readmission required constitutions and Fourteenth Amendment ratification. Tennessee had already been readmitted and was not placed in the five military districts.
Why Johnson’s Impeachment Belongs in This Conflict
The conflict also defined constitutional institutions. Johnson claimed executive authority over restoration and vetoed congressional civil-rights measures. Congressional Republicans used legislation, constitutional amendment, appropriations, investigation, and ultimately impeachment. Johnson’s impeachment involved the Tenure of Office Act but cannot be understood apart from the struggle over who would control Reconstruction. The Senate fell one vote short of conviction, leaving Johnson in office while congressional policy continued.
Compare the Policy Mechanisms
- Johnson’s 1865 proclamation
- Pardons and an oath restored many participants’ property rights, with stated exceptions and individual applications for excluded classes. Pardon was not a guarantee of equal rights for freedpeople.
- Congress’s 1867 framework
- Military districts and provisional governments supported a specified path to congressional representation. New constitutions, suffrage rules and amendment ratification became conditions, rather than relying on a presidential pardon alone.
Lincoln’s wartime proposals preceded Johnson’s implementation. Treat them as related stages, not identical policies or proof of what Lincoln would have done had he lived.
Watch and Evaluate the Explanation
Watch this account from Ms. Sutton's History with one question in mind: which evidence makes the lesson's strongest claim hold up?
Video: U.S. History: Presidential and Congressional Reconstruction (c. 1865-1870), Ms. Sutton's History.
Check your understanding
- Johnson’s approach allowed
- immediate Black suffrage everywhere.
- rapid southern reorganization under broad pardons.
- permanent military rule.
- land redistribution to all freed families.
- Fourteenth Amendment ratification before any government formed.
- Congressional Reconstruction required the ten unreconstructed states to
- retain their Johnson-era governments after accepting only the Thirteenth Amendment.
- seek individual presidential pardons in place of holding new constitutional conventions.
- regain full congressional representation before Congress addressed national citizenship protections.
- create governments based on Black male suffrage and ratify the Fourteenth Amendment.
- repudiate Confederate debt while preserving their existing suffrage rules and officeholders.
- Select all congressional measures:
- Civil Rights Act,
- Fourteenth Amendment,
- Reconstruction Acts,
- Bureau renewal,
- Black Codes.
- Compare what presidential and congressional plans treated as necessary for restoration.
Write a brief response using a named fact from the lesson.
Open the answers and reasoning
Independent preparation. CLEP is a registered trademark of the College Board, which does not endorse this lesson.
Related to This Article
More math articles
- Oregon Algebra 1 Free Worksheets: Printable Algebra 1 Practice with Answer Keys
- How Can Redefining a Function’s Value Solve Your Limit Problems
- Math Education in the Digital Age: Techniques for Today’s Classroom
- Scientific Notation Calculator & Converter
- The Best Algebra 1 Book for Maine Students
- The Ultimate Ready to Work Algebra 1 Course (+FREE Worksheets)
- FREE 3rd Grade Common Core Math Practice Test
- Subtracting Decimals for 5th Grade: Regrouping and Practice
- Overview of the PSAT / NMSQT Mathematics Test
- Marginal product pulls average product
What people say about "Presidential vs. Congressional Reconstruction: Plans Compared"?
No one replied yet.