Algebra

Extraneous Solution

A pupil sets aside a puzzle piece that fails the original fit test.

Extraneous Solution definition

An extraneous solution is a candidate that solves a transformed equation but fails to solve the original one.

In Spanish
solución extraña
Topic
Rational expressions and equations

Extraneous Solution in a picture

Extraneous Solution diagramSquaring gives a candidate, but substituting it into the original equation rejects it.√x = −2The square root is nonnegativeSquare both sides: x = 4A candidate appears√4 = 2, not −2The candidate is extraneous
Squaring gives a candidate, but substituting it into the original equation rejects it.

How it works

An operation such as squaring can allow a candidate that violates an original sign condition. Clearing denominators can also produce a candidate at an input that was originally undefined. Substitute every candidate into the original equation and keep only those that satisfy it.

Worked examples

Is x = 9 a solution to √x = 3?

Yes, because the original equation holds.

Squaring √x = −3 gives x = 9. Is the candidate valid?

No, because √9 = 3.

Can an undefined input solve the original rational equation?

No. It must be discarded.

Common mistake

Check the original equation. Testing only the transformed equation can preserve an extraneous candidate.

Quick check

Does an extraneous candidate satisfy the original equation?

Show answer

No.

What step detects it?

Show answer

Substitution into the original equation.

Can squaring both sides introduce such a candidate?

Show answer

Yes.

Sources

Flashcard

Extraneous Solution

Reveal the definition

An extraneous solution is a candidate that solves a transformed equation but fails to solve the original one.

Effortless Math. “Extraneous Solution.” Math Dictionary.