Choose the best answer, check your reasoning, and use the explanation to correct any gap.
All questions and explanations are available below. Turn on JavaScript for instant scoring.
Question 1 of 4
A. The lower judgment remains in place, but the denial does not endorse its reasoning
Denial of certiorari leaves the lower-court judgment undisturbed but is not a merits decision and does not signal approval of the lower court's reasoning. The denial creates no Supreme Court holding on the legal issue.
Question 2 of 4
B. concurring opinion
A concurrence agrees with the judgment while offering different or additional reasoning. A dissent disagrees with the judgment, while majority and plurality opinions describe support for an opinion rather than this justice's separate agreement in result.
Question 3 of 4
C. The five-justice opinion supplies the controlling holding
A majority of participating justices joined the same opinion, so its necessary reasoning supplies the controlling holding. Concurrences and dissents may persuade future readers but do not authorize lower courts to disregard that majority.
Question 4 of 4
D. The lower judgment remains in place, but the denial expresses no view on the merits
Denying certiorari leaves the lower court's judgment in place but does not endorse its reasoning or create Supreme Court precedent. The Court's discretionary docket allows it to decline review for many reasons unrelated to the merits.